How to Pick Winners Almost Every Time

Hiring & Retention of Employees   Written by Mel Kleiman - Word Count: 1395
- -    

At the racetrack, in the stock market, and when it comes to employee selection, the people who beat the odds most often use a system.

Most business people rely on systems to handle tasks as diverse as accounting, communications, inventory control, and security (to name just a few). We invest in systems because they create consistent results by automating processes and ensuring everyone does the same things the same way every time.

While personnel costs are one of the most expensive entries on any company’s balance sheet, most employers don’t have a system to ensure they realize a return on their investment. Even in spite of the fact we all know bad hiring decisions can raise your blood pressure, sink morale, erode profits, or, worst of all, land you in court.

The best employee selection systems start with a recruiting effort that attracts the best. After all, the best you can hire won’t be any better than the best of those who apply.

Because you can’t find what you need if you don’t know what it looks like, the only way to find the best is to map out exactly what it is you’re looking for. This entails developing a job analysis that lists the required mental and physical capacities (ability to learn, IQ, strength, stamina, eyesight, hearing, etc.), attitudes (dependability, safety-orientation, etc.), personality traits (energy level, attention to detail, etc.), and the job-related skills needed to be successful.

The next step is developing an on-going recruiting program. Most employers miss the boat here by recruiting only when they have a job opening. This approach severely limits your chances of hiring the best. Feeling pressured to hire causes you to be less selective and increases the odds you’ll hire the wrong person.

To get top quality employees, go after them just as persistently and proactively as you do new customers. When you invest a few minutes a day, a few hours a week in recruiting activities, you have a much better chance of finding what you need.

You’ve learned from experience you usually aren’t going to attract the best with a three line classified ad or a Now Hiring sign. In today’s tight labor market, all the people who want to work are working! In order to compete, you’ll have to be creative.

First, review each job analysis and target your recruiting toward people with the qualifications and attitudes you need. Where do these kinds of people congregate, socialize, work, shop, get information? Where do they spend their leisure time? How will you get their attention?

A business that hires teenagers thought about where teens spend time and bought ad space on the screen at the local movie theater. They got some great applicants and noticed an increase in new customers as well.

A Houston client needed air-conditioning repair people one July when all potential applicants were employed and working overtime. He advertised on a billboard across from the air-conditioning supply house and heard from 22 qualified applicants in one week.

Where are your target applicants likely to be? What do they read? What do they do on weekends? Why should they work for you? What’s in it for them? Answer these questions and you’ll discover a variety of recruiting opportunities and the recruiting messages that work.

An effective and overlooked source of applicants is every good employee who has ever worked for you. When they leave you for new employment, many discover the grass really isn’t greener somewhere else after all. At the hiring workshops I conduct, we find about 20 to 25 percent of the people in the audience are working at a company they once left. If 20 percent of all the good people who ever left you came back, you’d have instantaneously productive employees requiring little or no training.

Tap into this source by calling former good employees. Find out what they’re doing and ask if they’d like to come back. If the answer is: “No,” ask, “Do you know anyone else who might be interested?” Create a reminder system that schedules you to call good former employees a month or so after they leave.

Another great source of recruits is everyone working for you now. Research shows referral candidates are three times more likely to be a good match for the job. This is because your employees give them more detailed information about the job requirements and working conditions than you will. As a result, candidates are only likely to proceed with the selection process if they feel they fit the job. They’re also less likely to quit or be fired within the first few months.

An employee referral reward program is a way to get your employees involved in your recruiting efforts. Let them know what you’re looking for, give rewards immediately, and create some excitement around it.

The most relied upon source of applicants, classified advertising, is next in terms of effectiveness. However, there are ways to ensure you make the most of your investment.

Write headlines that appeal to the type of person you need. Want someone looking to build a career from the ground up? Use “Come Grow with Us.” Want part-time students? Use “Earn While You Learn.” Think about what it is you offer that your target market wants and turn it into your headline.

The best day of the week to advertise is Sunday. The multiple day packages offered by newspapers aren’t worth it. Ninety-nine percent of the people looking for work read only the Sunday classifieds.

Your community, business partners, and networking groups are also good sources of applicants. Put the word out. Churches, bowling leagues, your suppliers, clients, and your neighboring businesses know of applicants you’d otherwise never reach.

Due to economic expansion and population shifts, there are more jobs to fill than young people entering the labor pool. There are alternatives however.

The Small Business Job Protection Act of 1996 authorized the Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC) Program to help move people from welfare to work. By hiring certain job seekers, employers can reduce their federal tax liability by as much as $2,100 per qualified new worker. For more information, call WOTC at 800-695-6879.

Several states bond former inmates convicted of non-violent crimes. Some, like Texas, train and support parolees through work-release programs. (Employers taking this option need to diligently protect themselves against negligent hiring lawsuits.)

Whatever creative recruiting ideas you employ, you’ve got to make it easy for applicants to apply. I’ve been telling clients how important this is for years – especially for hourly jobs. In today’s tight labor market, it’s even more important. Don’t make applicants jump through hoops to make that initial contact. The people who are already working can’t easily get in touch with you during normal business hours.

If you don’t put job openings on your website, increase your chances of success by setting up a 24-Hour Job Hotline. This can be as simple as a separate phone line with an answering machine which tells a little bit about the job and asks for the person’s name, phone number, and best time for you to call them back. Or it can be a sophisticated software program like the one we’ve developed which gives the person an initial interview and reports the results back to you. Do whatever you can to make it as easy as possible for the applicant to get things moving.

If you think you’ll never have the time needed to build a recruiting system, consider one of the most successful businessmen I’ve ever met. This owner of 14 different businesses, including a chain of convenience stores, told me he was taking the time to attend my seminar because: “I only have one job and that’s to hire the right people. If I hire the right people, I don’t have to do anything else.”


blog comments powered by Disqus

Mel Kleiman is a nationally-known authority and consultant on employee recruiting, selection, and retention. This article is excerpted in part from Mel Kleiman’s latest book, "Hire Tough, Manage Easy." He also serves as president of Humetrics, Incorporated, which provides employee recruiting and selection systems, pre-employment testing, as well as educational presentations and in-depth training workshops. For more informationl,



Copyright (Reprint Terms)
Copyright© 2002, Mel Kleiman. All right reserved. For information contact FrogPond at email susie@FrogPond.com.