Clicks and Mortar: Brokerage In The E-Age

Broker Business Development   Written by John Tuccillo - Word Count: 632
- -    

I would be the last one to suggest that real estate firms should fight against the trend toward e-commerce. In fact, I think that the industry is moving far to slowly to respond to competition from Web-based companies. With the emergence of Ziprealty, E-home, Global Staake and E-Realty, the battle has been joined--and it must be fought. While these firms are for the moment just straws in the win, they nevertheless pose a challenge to real estate no less significant than that presented by Charles Schwab and E-trade to the traditional stock brokerage industry.

But, how far should the typical real estate firm go toward the e-commerce model. Let's begin with a basic premise: you must have a web presence.  Without it, you cannot compete with other firms. Technology will not replace Realtors, but Realtors with technology will replace Realtors without technology. Make the effort to hire a technologist or partner with a technology firm to create your electronic identity.

Yet, that isn’t the whole story. Unlike stock brokerage, or travel, or insurance, real estate is not very easily made into a commodity. Each property is unique and irreproduceable, so the human touch remains (and will remain) the essential part of the market. You will need some degree of physical presence. There are three areas where clicks will never replace bricks:

Customer Service.

This is the core of the new economy. Since the consumer calls the shots, creating a consumer value proposition is the key to profit and growth. Delivering excellent customer service requires investment, but this time in people, backed by excellent electronic tools.

Knowledge Delivery.

Information is worthless. It can be found less costly on the Web for just about every industry. Real estate has even gone so far as to create its own utility (Home Store) to distribute information. But knowledge--actionable information--is priceless and that can only be delivered through dialogue between real people.

Marketing.

Banner ads have proliferated on the Web, but they do not have the status of a full marketing campaign directed by marketing professionals through media that reach real customers.

Please do not mistake these words for justification of the status quo…quite the contrary. The status quo is strangling the real estate industry and will ultimately cause it to be devoured by the new competitors. The uses of bricks and mortar described above do not represent the current activities of traditional real estate firms. Most companies still adhere to the "feet on the street" philosophy of marketing, setting up stores wherever the opportunity arises and still focusing on possessing the information contained in the local MLS.

The electronic model will not overwhelm the real estate business but it will force fundamental changes in the current business model. Unless you can migrate your company to a "clicks and mortar" model, mixing e-commerce and physical presence to deliver true consumer value, you'll find that the parade has passed you by.  


blog comments powered by Disqus

John Tuccillo, Ph.D., CAE, is one of the country's foremost speakers and authors on real estate markets, the economy and business strategy. Dr. Tuccillo was Chief Economist for the National Council of Savings Institutions for four years and the National Association of Realtors for ten years. He is now an independent consultant specializing in strategic and business planning, economic forecasting and real estate market analysis. He is the author of the recent book, The Eight New Rules of Real Estate, which has been widely received as the best new book in the business in years. For information about John’s Keynote presentations and consulting,



Copyright (Reprint Terms)
Copyright© 2002, John Tuccillo. All right reserved. For information contact FrogPond at email susie@FrogPond.com.